Cell Relay Archive

Cell Relay Retreat>List Archive>month:1998-Jul> msg00233



[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]  
  [Date Index][Thread Index][Author Index][Subject Index]

Re: what's the fate of ATM in the face of coming threat?

  • From: Yu Ning <yuning@mindless.com>
  • Date: 21 Jul 1998 03:15:04 GMT

Hi,
>A technology designed from the beginning to handle all types of 
>data is easier to modify, enhance, and maintain for new network
>applications than is a technology (IP) that was designed to 
>slowly move ASCII text files from point A to point B.
>
But the situation now is not to compare ATM and IP. ATM in its own is a
perfect tech, but chances never been given to ATM to deploy a worldwide
ATM infrastructure. The demanding task, and its real world practice for
ATM is to support upper layer IP service, then ATM shows its "disadvantage"
over POS, which is a natrual extension to router model.

What's more, IP is no longer IP years ago. Rooted is best-effort model,
IP has shift to a multi-service platfrom. Many Cos/QoS ability has been
added, or is adding to IP protocol suite. IETF Intserv, issl, rsvp, rap
are on their busy works.


Yu Ning.

----------------------------------------------------------------------*
Yu Ning
ATM R&D Center
BUPT (Beijing U. of Posts&Telecom)
Beijing  (ZIP: 100876,  MBox: 147#),   P. R. China
Tel:86-10-62283123; Fax:86-10-62283124
mailto:yuning@mindless.com or  yuning@263.net
-------------------------------------------------------------------------