The IP Over NBMA (ION) Archive

[Bruce Cole <bcole@cisco.com>]

> > Here's the draft agenda for Montreal.  Please reply to George and me if
> > we've left you off by mistake, or you see some other problem with it.
> > We'll also do the usual agenda bashing at the beginning of the meeting.
> 
> 
> > Third session, Tuesday, 6/25 1530-1730:
> 
> > - Multicast Inscalability over Large Cloud (Ohta)
> >   draft-ietf-ohta-mcast-large-cloud-01, 15-20 minutes
> 
> The placement of my draft in the proposed agenda is fine for me,
> though it will be more productive to remove all the NHRP related
> presentations from the agenda.
> 
> The proof was available as an Internet Draft just before the last
> IETF meeting and disscussed there. And, I reminded the member of
> ION about the draft several weeks ago.

I don't recall anyone agreeing with you that your very thin draft obviates
NHRP.  Your second draft elaborates a bit more, but seems to assume ATM,
multicast, and RSVP.  How, for example, does this obviate the use of NHRP over
X25 for unicast address resolution?

I must admit, I'm having a lot of trouble understanding your English.  Perhaps
this is why you have not received so many objections.